Best protein ice cream: Choosing between the popular brands

Protein ice cream has become a popular item in the freezer aisle. What was once a small specialty category—a few pints next to the regular ice cream—is now a whole section, with brands competing on protein counts, ingredient lists, and flavor lineups. Social media has accelerated the trend considerably, with videos showing people eating entire pints of protein ice cream as post-workout meals or late-night treats.

Eating a full pint as a meal isn’t the intent here, but there’s nothing wrong with enjoying these in moderation. But how do you choose from the many options to find the one that fits your goals and needs? The options vary more than the packaging suggests. 

Despite the similar packaging and nutrition claims of higher protein, these products aren’t interchangeable. Some maximize protein. Others prioritize fewer calories, lower sugar, or shorter ingredient lists. And depending on the brand, you may find anything from cream and milk to protein isolates, sugar alcohols, or alternative sweeteners.

This guide compares nine of the most widely available protein frozen desserts side by side including Yasso, Nick’s, Protein Pints, Swoop, Halo Top, Rebel, Frozen One, Blue Bell PRO, and David Protein We’ll look at protein, calories, ingredients, sweeteners, and whether each product actually qualifies as ice cream under FDA standards—so you can choose the one that best fits your goals and preferences.

Maggie Hudspeth, RDN, Senior Coach Program Manager at Noom, also shares what she looks for when comparing protein ice creams and the tradeoffs worth considering before adding one to your cart.

Protein ice cream: Why ingredients vary so much

“Protein is worth paying attention to, but it shouldn’t be the only number you look at. Two pints with the same protein count can hit your body very differently depending on what else is in there. I always tell people: flip it over and read the ingredient list. If you can’t recognize most of what’s on it, that’s worth knowing before you decide it’s a food you want to eat,” says Hudspeth.

Two pints can both claim 20 grams of protein while having very different ingredient profiles—one made with milk and cream, another with skim milk, protein concentrates, alternative sweeteners, and stabilizers. That’s because brands use different approaches to increase protein, reduce calories, lower sugar, or create a particular texture.

A few things worth comparing before you choose:

• Protein per serving: Varies widely depending on ingredients, serving size, and brand.
• Ingredient list: Some brands rely primarily on dairy ingredients, while others include protein concentrates, stabilizers, or other functional ingredients. Sweeteners also vary from sugar to alternative sweeteners and sugar alcohols.
• Sweetener type: Different brands use different sweetener systems, including cane sugar, coconut nectar, allulose, monk fruit, stevia, erythritol, sucralose, or blends of several sweeteners.
• Dairy base: Products range from whole milk and cream to skim milk, Greek yogurt, or whey protein–based formulations. Some use little or no traditional dairy base.

Is protein ice cream actually ice cream?

Under FDA standards, a product labeled “ice cream” must contain at least 10% milkfat and meet specific compositional requirements. Many high-protein frozen desserts don’t meet that standard because increasing protein while keeping calories lower often changes the amount of milkfat in the final product. Instead, brands may use labels such as “light ice cream,” “frozen dairy dessert,” or “protein frozen dessert,” depending on how the product is formulated.

These labels describe differences in formulation rather than quality. Compared with traditional ice cream, protein frozen desserts often use lower-fat dairy, additional milk proteins, or other ingredients to achieve their nutrition goals. Those choices can also affect texture. Products made with more cream tend to be richer and creamier, while those made primarily with skim milk and added proteins may have a lighter or airier texture.

In the table below, the “Is it ice cream?” column reflects whether each product is marketed as ice cream under FDA standards, based on the brand’s labeling and publicly available product information.

Protein ice cream brands: How they compare 

While every brand in this comparison is marketed as a high-protein frozen dessert, the nutrition profiles vary considerably. Some pack more than 10 grams of protein into a serving, while others provide about half that amount. Calories range from just over 50 per serving to around 200, and added sugar ranges from none to 14 grams. Looking at the numbers side by side makes it easier to compare the tradeoffs.

Brand	Protein (serving/pint)	Calories (serving/pint)
Blue Bell PRO	11 g / 33 g	100 / 300
Frozen One	10 g / 40 g	120 / 480
Swoop	8 g / 32 g	150 / 600
Protein Pints	8 g / 32 g	140 / 560
David Protein	7.5 g / 30 g	53 / 210
Yasso	5 g / 20 g	100 / 400
Nick’s	5 g / 20 g	70 / 280
Halo Top	5 g / 20 g	90 / 360
Rebel	3 g / 12 g	200 / 800

*All data from brand official product pages, vanilla or closest equivalent flavor. Note: David Protein pints are currently sold online only. Serving sizes vary by brand.

A few patterns stand out. 

• Blue Bell PRO and Frozen One provide the most protein per serving, while David Protein has the fewest calories. 
• Rebel has the lowest protein of the group but the highest calories and saturated fat because it’s made with a cream-forward formula that more closely resembles traditional ice cream. 
• Protein Pints and Swoop fall in the middle for protein while taking different approaches to sweetening. 
• Halo Top, Nick’s, and Yasso offer more modest protein amounts with different calorie and sugar profiles. 

As with any packaged food, it’s worth checking the nutrition label on the specific flavor you’re buying, since values can vary across a brand’s lineup.

Brand-by-brand breakdown

Nutrition is only part of the story. Brands also differ in the type of dairy they use, the sweeteners they choose, and whether they meet the FDA definition of ice cream. Some focus on maximizing protein, while others prioritize fewer calories, a shorter ingredient list, or a creamier texture. Here’s a closer look at what distinguishes each brand.

Brand	What to know	Is it ice cream?	Notable flavors
Yasso	Base: Greek yogurt made with nonfat milk and live cultures. Stands out for: A frozen yogurt base with cane sugar and no sugar alcohols. Sweetener: Cane sugar.	No — Frozen Greek yogurt	Cookies ’n Cream, Coffee Chocolate Chip, Fudge Brownie, Mint Chocolate Chip
Frozen One	Base: Skim milk and milk protein concentrate. Stands out for: The highest protein per pint in this comparison. Sweetener: Allulose and monk fruit.	No — Frozen dairy dessert	Chocolate, Peanut Butter Chip, Apple Pie, Salted Caramel Crunch
Blue Bell PRO	Base: Milk, skim milk, and milk protein concentrate. Stands out for: A traditional ice cream texture with one of the highest protein contents per serving. Sweetener: Allulose, erythritol, sucralose, and acesulfame potassium (Ace-K).	Yes	Vanilla, Chocolate, Coffee, Salted Caramel, Strawberry
David Protein	Base: Whey protein isolate, milk protein isolate, and EPG (modified plant-based fat). Stands out for: The lowest calories per pint in this comparison. Sweetener: Allulose, sucralose, monk fruit, and stevia. Also worth knowing: Currently sold online only.	No — Protein frozen dessert	Vanilla Bean, Triple Chocolate, Triple Peanut Butter, Cookie Dough
Swoop	Base: Whey protein isolate with avocado oil (water-based rather than dairy-based). Stands out for: A short ingredient list and coconut nectar as its only sweetener. Sweetener: Organic coconut nectar.	No — Protein frozen dessert	Vanilla Surge, Chocolate Charge, Mighty Mint Chip, Peanut Butter Chip Blitz
Protein Pints	Base: Whole milk, cream, and whey protein isolate. Stands out for: A whole dairy base with relatively low added sugar. Sweetener: Allulose and monk fruit.	No — Frozen dairy dessert	Chocolate, Cookie Dough, Cookies & Cream, Mint Chip, Peanut Butter Chip, Salted Caramel
Nick’s	Base: Cream, milk protein concentrate, and whey protein isolate. Stands out for: A lower-calorie, keto-friendly formula. Sweetener: Allulose, erythritol, and steviol glycosides.	No — Light ice cream	Swedish Vanilj, Cookies and Kräm, Swedish Choklad, Swedish Cookie Dough
Halo Top	Base: Ultrafiltered skim milk. Stands out for: Wide availability in grocery stores. Sweetener: Erythritol, stevia, and cane sugar.	No — Light ice cream	Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, Peanut Butter Cup, Cookies & Cream, Birthday Cake
Rebel	Base: Cream and egg yolks. Stands out for: A cream-forward, keto-friendly formula with a richer texture. Sweetener: Erythritol and monk fruit.	Yes	Vanilla, Chocolate, Cookie Dough, Cherry Chip, Mint Chip, Peanut Butter

Every brand on this list takes a slightly different approach to making a higher-protein frozen dessert. Some rely on skim milk or added milk proteins to boost protein while keeping calories lower, while others use more cream to create a richer texture. Sweeteners also vary widely, from cane sugar and coconut nectar to allulose, monk fruit, erythritol, stevia, and sucralose. Those choices affect not only nutrition, but also taste, texture, and how each product fits different dietary preferences.

“Rather than looking for one “best” protein ice cream, think about which qualities matter most to you. Whether you’re prioritizing more protein, fewer calories, a particular sweetener, or a traditional ice cream experience, comparing the nutrition label and ingredient list can help you find the option that best fits your preferences,” says Hudspeth.

Frequently asked questions about protein ice cream

Is protein ice cream actually good for you?

Compared with traditional ice cream, protein ice cream generally provides more protein and, in many cases, fewer calories and less added sugar per serving. But nutrition profiles and ingredient lists vary considerably by brand. Some products rely on alternative sweeteners or added milk proteins to achieve their nutrition targets, while others use more traditional dairy ingredients. If you’re looking for a higher-protein dessert, protein ice cream can fit into a balanced eating pattern alongside other nutrient-rich foods.

Is protein ice cream good for weight loss?

Protein ice cream can support weight management when it’s used in place of a higher-calorie dessert rather than added to your usual diet. Many brands provide more protein and fewer calories than traditional ice cream, which may make them a satisfying alternative. As with any dessert, portion size still matters, so it’s helpful to consider how it fits into your overall eating pattern.

How much protein should ice cream have to count as “high protein”?

There isn’t an official definition of “high-protein” ice cream. In general, 5 grams or more of protein per serving is a reasonable benchmark, while products with 20 grams or more per pint stand out from traditional ice cream. In this comparison, Frozen One and Blue Bell PRO provide the most protein per serving, while every brand delivers at least 20 grams of protein per pint except Rebel.

Can you eat protein ice cream every day?

For most people, protein ice cream can be enjoyed regularly as part of a balanced diet. The key is considering how it fits into your overall nutrition. If it’s replacing another dessert, it may help you increase your protein intake. It shouldn’t crowd out foods that provide nutrients protein ice cream doesn’t, like lean protein, fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and healthy fats.

Is protein ice cream a good choice for people with diabetes?

Some protein ice creams contain less added sugar and fewer digestible carbohydrates than traditional ice cream, but nutrition profiles vary by brand. People with diabetes may also have different preferences regarding sweeteners such as allulose, erythritol, or sucralose. Checking the Nutrition Facts label and ingredient list can help you choose a product that fits your individual needs, and it’s a good idea to discuss dietary changes with your healthcare provider if you have diabetes.

Is Blue Bell PRO available nationwide?

No. Blue Bell products are sold in 24 states, primarily in the South and Southeast. Check the company’s store locator for current availability.

Is David Protein ice cream available in stores?

Not yet. David Protein pints are currently sold online through the company’s website in packs of six and ship within the contiguous United States.

What happened to Enlightened ice cream?

As of mid-2026, Enlightened has paused production and is no longer widely available in stores. If you’re looking for a similar product, Protein Pints and Frozen One offer comparable protein content with a similar nutrition focus.

The bottom line: The best protein ice cream depends on what you’re optimizing for

Protein ice creams all aim to provide more protein than traditional ice cream, but they take different approaches to getting there. Some maximize protein, others keep calories low, and others prioritize a shorter ingredient list or a creamier texture. The best choice depends on what matters most to you.

If protein is your top priority, Frozen One and Blue Bell PRO lead the pack. If you’re looking for the fewest calories, David Protein and Nick’s stand out. If you prefer a shorter ingredient list, Swoop and Protein Pints are worth considering. And if you want a richer, more traditional ice cream experience, Rebel and Blue Bell PRO come closest to the texture of conventional ice cream.

“The best protein ice cream isn’t the one with the highest protein or the fewest calories—it’s the one that fits your goals and that you’ll actually enjoy eating,” says Hudspeth. “Some people care most about protein, others want a shorter ingredient list or a more traditional ice cream texture. And for some people, regular ice cream may simply be the dessert they enjoy most. Protein ice cream isn’t meant to replace nutrient-rich foods—it’s another option in the freezer aisle. Once you know what you’re looking for, comparing the label becomes much easier.”

Whatever you choose, check the label and ingredient list on the specific flavor you’re buying, since formulations can vary within the same brand. Protein ice cream can be a satisfying dessert or snack when it fits your overall eating pattern, but no single product needs to do it all. The option that’s easiest to enjoy consistently—and that aligns with your preferences and nutrition goals—is likely to be the best fit.

For more tips on shaping healthy eating habits, download Noom for free on iOS and Android.